Get Help Now
Call or email for a confidential consultation
Get Help Now
Call or email for a confidential consultation
Children are not typically trusted to choose their own path, making it the responsibility of parents to steer a child’s life in the right direction. If you are involved in a battle for custody, you are likely worried about losing the ability to make an impact on your child’s future.
Our Pittsburgh custody lawyers at Pittsburgh Divorce & Family Law, LLC understand that fighting for custody can be stressful. Attorney Anthony Piccirilli will guide you through the process of obtaining legal custody under Pennsylvania law, keeping you informed every step of the way.
Call (412) 471-5100 now to find out how we can help you.
In Pennsylvania, custody is divided into two categories: legal custody and physical custody. Most people know that physical custody concerns where the child will live and who provides day-to-day care, but legal custody covers a separate and equally important set of responsibilities.
Legal custody is the right and responsibility of a parent to make long-term decisions about a child’s upbringing. Under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5322, legal custody includes the authority to make major choices for the child in areas such as:
Legal custody touches the choices that shape a child’s long-term wellbeing rather than the day-to-day routine. A parent with legal custody has the authority to make major life decisions for the child, often in coordination with the other parent. The categories most frequently raised in Allegheny County Family Division cases include education, healthcare, religion, and extracurricular activities.
Legal custody covers selecting the child’s school, whether public, private, charter, cyber, or homeschool. Parents with shared legal custody must agree on enrollment changes, special education plans, tutoring services, and major academic interventions such as grade retention. Disputes over school district selection are common when one parent moves within Allegheny County or to a surrounding county such as Washington, Beaver, Butler, or Westmoreland.
Routine sick visits rarely require joint sign-off, but legal custody covers selecting a primary care physician, approving non-emergency surgery, consenting to mental health treatment and counseling, and choosing an orthodontist or specialist. Emergency medical care can always proceed without prior notice to the other parent.
Legal custody includes the religion in which the child is raised, the practice of religious rituals such as baptism or bar and bat mitzvah, and decisions about religious schooling. Pennsylvania courts are generally reluctant to favor one parent’s faith over the other and often encourage continued exposure to both family traditions when the parents practice different religions.
Choosing sports, music lessons, summer camps, and other enrichment activities also falls under legal custody. Conflicts can arise when activities cut into the other parent’s custodial time, when one parent objects to the cost, or when the activity carries an elevated risk of injury.
In every custody case, the best interest of the child is the chief concern. Pennsylvania courts evaluate legal custody petitions under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328, which lists 16 factors a judge must weigh. These include each parent’s role in the child’s life, the child’s relationships with siblings and extended family, each parent’s ability to provide stability, and whether either parent has a history of abuse or neglect. For a deeper look at the statutory analysis, see how Pennsylvania courts determine custody.
Legal custody can be awarded jointly or solely. Most Pennsylvania custody orders include shared legal custody, since keeping both parents involved in major decisions typically serves the child’s best interest. Granting sole custody is appropriate when one parent is unable or unwilling to participate constructively in major decisions, when there is a documented history of abuse, or when ongoing conflict between the parents makes joint decision-making unworkable.
Courts only issue custody orders after careful consideration of every relevant factor. Common factors include, but are not limited to:
Pennsylvania law recognizes two arrangements for legal custody, and the arrangement chosen by the court directly affects how decisions are made for the child and how the parents must communicate going forward.
Shared legal custody is the more common outcome when both parents are fit and able to cooperate. Under shared legal custody, both parents have an equal say in major decisions. Neither parent can unilaterally enroll the child in a new school, switch the child to a new pediatrician, or change the child’s religious upbringing without the other parent’s input. Shared legal custody can be paired with any physical custody arrangement, including one in which the child primarily lives with one parent. For more on how living arrangements are structured, see our overview of physical custody arrangements.
Sole legal custody gives one parent the authority to make major decisions without consulting the other. The non-custodial parent typically retains the right to be informed about the child’s school records and medical care, but does not have decision-making authority. Pennsylvania courts award sole legal custody less frequently than shared legal custody and generally require evidence that joint decision-making would harm the child. Examples include:
Legal custody is also distinct from physical custody. A parent can have shared legal custody while exercising limited physical custody, and the reverse is also possible. Many Pennsylvania custody orders combine shared legal custody with a primary-residence physical custody schedule.
Shared legal custody works well when parents can put aside personal differences and focus on what is best for the child. When they cannot, Pennsylvania law provides several paths to resolve specific disputes without rewriting the entire custody order.
Parents who cannot reach a decision on a major issue generally proceed in this order:
A single disagreement rarely justifies converting shared legal custody into sole legal custody. Courts look for a pattern of bad-faith decision-making, ongoing conflict that harms the child, or an outright refusal by one parent to participate. Even then, a court may grant sole legal custody on one specific issue, such as medical decisions, while preserving shared decision-making on everything else. A well-drafted parenting plan can also designate one parent as the tie-breaker on certain categories of decisions to reduce future disputes.
Legal custody is the authority to make long-term decisions about a child’s upbringing, including education, medical care, religion, and extracurricular activities. Physical custody is where the child lives and which parent provides day-to-day care. Pennsylvania courts award them separately, and most custody orders address both. A parent can have shared legal custody but limited physical custody, or the reverse.
No. Under shared legal custody in Pennsylvania, both parents must be involved in major decisions about the child’s welfare. A parent who unilaterally changes the child’s school, religion, or medical provider can be ordered by the court to reverse the change and may face contempt proceedings or a modification of the custody arrangement.
Courts award sole legal custody when shared decision-making would harm the child. Common grounds include a documented history of abuse, substance abuse that interferes with parenting, untreated mental illness that affects judgment, repeated refusal to communicate or cooperate, or an extended absence from the child’s life. The parent seeking sole legal custody must show that the arrangement serves the child’s best interest under the 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328 factors.
Yes. Pennsylvania law gives both parents the right to access the child’s school records, medical records, and similar information unless a court order specifies otherwise. Even a parent with sole physical custody must share this information with the other parent when legal custody is shared.
Yes. Either parent can petition the court to modify legal custody at any time. The court will grant a modification only when the change serves the child’s best interest. A petition to switch from shared to sole legal custody typically requires showing a substantial change in circumstances, such as ongoing parental conflict that harms the child, a relocation that makes joint decision-making impractical, or a parent’s failure to participate in major decisions.
If you are trying to obtain legal custody of your child, the process can feel cold and unfair, as though no one is taking your perspective into consideration. You are a parent, and you deserve the opportunity to be involved in making long-term decisions about your child’s welfare.
Our Pittsburgh custody attorneys at Pittsburgh Divorce & Family Law, LLC understand that a fight for custody can uproot everything you have worked to build. With years of experience helping parents across Allegheny County and the surrounding region, we will work to ensure that your case is presented in the best possible light. Call (412) 471-5100 today to schedule a consultation with attorney Anthony Piccirilli and protect your relationship with your child.